Food allergies in dogs can be tricky to identify. Over the years, dog food makers have been more imaginative in coming up with new protein sources such as kangaroo and fish. Dioxin is a by-product of the industrial process used in many manufacturing factories. According to many veterinarians and nutritionists, a raw food diet is the best thing you can feed your dog. However, just like with any type of food, there are some dogs that are allergic to it. Here’s how you can figure out if your dog has food allergies and what you can do about them. The worst part is that it might be food your dog has enjoyed for years, and it can be any ingredient in that food. Usually, food allergies in dogs do not grow until after the age of three. A diet rich in salmon oil will slow down the blood cells and decrease their efficiency. malondialdehyde and free radicals can appear. While salmon oil is potentially dangerous for your dog, there are other similar supplements that can serve as substitutes. Wounds can take longer to heal, and during that time, they’re more exposed to infection. So, many dog parents add salmon oil supplements to make up for what their pooches are missing. Next, they will likely run tests to rule out conditions with similar symptoms like mange, ringworm, yeast infections, bacterial infections, flea infestations, and environmental allergies. Many fish oil products are made by vacuuming up fish in the ocean. Here are a couple of different approaches to treating food allergies in dogs. Be a Hero – Sign up to receive our emails today and we'll donate a meal to a shelter dog on your behalf. Unfortunately, these healthy omega fatty acids aren’t found naturally in your dog’s body. Everything about omega fatty acids in your dog’s diet sounds good, right? Sadly, this causes many other sea creatures to accidentally get hurt. For this reason, it’s important to track whether your dog’s symptoms ebb and flow with the changing of the seasons. Diagnosing a food allergy in dogs can be tricky because the symptoms of food allergies overlap with a variety of other conditions. If you’re concerned about any symptoms your dog is experiencing, or you’re simply wondering whether the food you’re offering is the best choice for your pet, speak with your veterinarian. This damage could lead to more serious health concerns, including cancer. If there is no other apparent cause for your dog’s symptoms, your veterinarian may begin to suspect that food allergies are behind your dog’s itchy skin or ear infections. But before you make a commitment, pay attention to the negative health effects you might not have known about. It’s not like there’s a simple test that can instantly tell what your dog is allergic to or, if indeed, he has food allergies at all. When you drizzle salmon oil over their kibble or mix it in as a pill, that’s extra calories your dog is consuming. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Once a diagnosis of food allergies seems to be a reasonable possibility, your vet will recommend a food trial. After all, it’s extracted straight from the oily tissues of fish. It contains essential omega-3 acids that promote bone and brain health. While your dog is chewing their way to better health, your purchase will also provide 14 meals for shelter dogs. The food is grain free for your dog’s health, lowering the risk of allergic or negative reactions. However, there are certain meats and grains that are more likely to cause an allergic reaction in your dog. This damage could lead to more serious health concerns, including cancer. If you believe your dog is allergic to the raw food diet they are on, there are very few ways to test this. Salmon oil for dogs can support your companion’s heart health, give them a shinier coat, soothe their itchy and irritated skin, and even relieve some of their allergies and joint pain. While dogs have the reputation of being able to eat anything and everything, many dogs experience food allergies. Rabbit, venison, and other novel ingredients are used in place of more common protein sources. The only effective way to treat a food allergy in dogs is to change their diet. This disease can be fatal. Unfortunately, many commercial dog foods contain multiple allergens so it can be difficult to pinpoint the particular ingredient that is causing your dog’s allergy. Kinds of foods to watch out for. So, your dog’s food shouldn’t contribute to this. Just like people, dogs can develop allergies to foods at any time – even after years of eating a certain type of food. How about canned salmon and dogs? Why Dog Food Allergies Are So Difficult to Deal With. There are a couple of nutritional matters to watch out for with fish, however, and you should always check with your pet’s veterinarian to see if salmon is right for your dog. However, food allergies in dogs may or may not come with an upset stomach. Food allergy symptoms can include dry, itchy, and flaky skin, paw-licking, and indigestion. A supplement like this seems like the answer to all your prayers. Even if your dog is only irritated by the symptoms initially, they could be life-threatening the next time they eat the problem food. Just like people, dogs can suffer from allergies. Fish oil production can harm the ocean. It contains 15% to 25% EPA and DHA (the essential nutrients in omega-3 fatty acids). Salmon oil is high in calories, and a high dosage could result in gradual weight gain. White blood cells usually rush to the injury to begin clotting and healing. Salmon is a novel protein for many dogs which can be beneficial if your dog suffers from food allergies or sensitivities to common proteins. Hypoallergenic dog food options include venison and potato, duck and pea, salmon and potato or even kangaroo, as long as the dog hasn’t been exposed to these ingredients in the past. Krill oil comes from a small marine organism called krill. It contains 15% to 25% EPA and DHA (the essential nutrients in omega-3 fatty acids). These small substances could cause disease or premature aging for your dog. In some cases, you may find out that your dog has a food intolerance. You can give canned salmon to your dog but be sure to choose salmon in water and avoid those that contain brine or oil, because the salt and oil can be harmful to your dog. A toxic chemical called dioxin is an example. Just like people, cats and dogs can have food allergies, too. They come in different sizes with specific dosing advice to ensure your dogs get the exact nutrients their bodies need. Yet, your dog still needs an ideal balance of both. This approach involves feeding proteins that your dog has likely never been exposed to in an effort to avoid an allergic reaction. The only way to treat a food allergy is to remove the offending food from the dog’s diet, but there are options for temporarily treating the symptoms caused by food allergies. It leaches into the ground and makes its way into streams and rivers where it comes in contact with fish. A food allergy can’t be cured but symptoms can be avoided by limiting your dog’s diet and not allowing them to eat the foods they are allergic to. It’s important to remember that food allergies can develop at any time. Dry skin, excessive itching and scratching, hot spots, and recurrent ear infections are all possible signs of a food allergy … Even if your vet finds a “reason” for your dog’s skin problems, they may still suspect that an adverse food reaction is at least partially responsible since, for example, yeast infections can develop as a result of food allergies. Lamb used to be considered hypoallergenic but is now in so many commercial dog foods that it is … Salmon oil is a popular choice among dog parents, but it has more risks than meets the eye. Dogs need specific amounts of omega-3 fatty acids to maintain shiny coats and healthy skin. In dogs, food intolerances typically cause tummy troubles; they may vomit or have diarrhea, be seriously gassy, or have a poor appetite. Your veterinarian will take a full history on your pet and do a general exam. The dog will have to get a type of meat he is not allergic to and if beef, pork or chicken are not tolerated by his digestive system, he can eat venison or ra… Fortunately, correcting the problem can be as simple as switching the dog food. It’s a healthy source of marine fat and protein that promotes coat health, cellular health, joint health, and immune system health. In dogs, food allergy symptoms are more likely to affect the skin than the digestive system, which can make them tricky to diagnose. And, because fish is low in fat, feeding your dog fish can be a good option if your pet needs to lose weight. Dogs can be tested for allergies. So, you never really know what lies inside fish oil products. A food your dog has consumed for years with no troubles may suddenly cause an allergic reaction, or symptoms may develop soon after you change your dog’s diet. If your dog has an allergic reaction to a certain meat, you may want to try a food with a new protein source that is new to your dog such as egg, duck, salmon, lamb, venison or whitefish. Symptoms in Cats and Dogs As an animal-based protein, salmon is a complete protein that provides all 10 of the essential amino acids your dog needs in his diet. An example is krill oil for dogs. Instead of assuming all dog food with fatty acids are good, pay attention to how much they contain. Its hypoallergenic ingredients are not only great for pups with sensitive stomachs, but also skin allergies, so they are guaranteed comfort. ).You might have wondered in that moment: Can I feed my dog with some salmon?. Dogs can be allergic to fleas, dust, pollen, mold, grass and, yes, even the food we feed them. In reality, though, you should already be planning the next protein to switch to. Allergies are usually more common in purebred dogs but can affect any breed. At first glance, this seems kind of odd, but it makes more sense when you think about how people react to food allergies. An example is krill oil for dogs. Salmon is very beneficial for humans. Some of the most common health issues associated with legitimate dog food allergies are: Skin lesions, especially when a dog is self-harming in an effort to scratch the itch. According to a study published in 2016, the top three most common causes of food allergies in dogs are beef, dairy, and chicken. Meat is a common allergen and the main culprits are beef and chicken,which are included in the majority of the foods that are made for dogs.Detecting if the dog is allergic to beef or chicken is easy: remove theingredient from the dog's diet for at least three weeks and see if he presents the same reactions. So, you never really know what lies inside fish oil products. Yet, salmon oil isn’t the only way for your pup to get the nutrients they need, and it isn’t always the best option. Featured Image: iStock.com/monkeybusinessimages, How to Tell if Your Dog Has Food Allergies, myths out there about food allergies in dogs, Similar symptoms may be caused by environmental allergies, How to Identify, Treat, and Prevent Dog Ear Infections, What Causes Dog Diarrhea and How to Treat It. Starting your dog on a food trial means your pet will eat a prescription diet and absolutely nothing else for a couple of months to see if symptoms resolve. These small substances could cause disease or premature aging for your dog. They do this by damaging cellular structures like proteins and DNA. Even so, your dog still needs these unusual fats in their body. True food allergies are not that common in dogs, for one. Dog allergies are a common problem that many canines are afflicted with, and oftentimes, those allergies are directly related to food. You have to start at the beginning, with the help of your veterinarian, to know for sure whether your dog’s skin or ear issues are caused by food allergies. However, studies show that one-third of all dogs who develop a food allergy are under the age of one year. Consuming even small amounts of these toxins can prove extremely dangerous over time. Lamb used to be the go-to hypoallergenic food, as chicken and beef are more commonly used in dog food. If you suspect your pet has a food allergy, a fish-based diet can be a good protein source. Help us fund One Last Home for senior hospice dogs! PCPs used in electronic devices, heavy metals like lead and mercury, and other carcinogens may also end up in salmon oil supplements. They can start even if your cat or dog has been eating the same food for months or years. https://www.petmd.com/dog/nutrition/how-tell-if-your-dog-has-food-allergies They’re found in cold-water fish, shellfish, flaxseed, and oils from nuts and plants. They create crucial hormones in your dog’s body that can better regulate blood flow and inflammation. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Giving This To Your Dog Daily Could Help With Painful Skin Itchiness, The 75 Best Holiday Gift Ideas For Dogs & Dog Lovers, Kabo Review: Canada’s New Fresh Dog Food Delivery Brand, 12 Pawdorable Christmas Decor Items That Will Make Your Guests Say WOW, Try One of the Most Popular Canine Joint Pain Supplements for Under $15, Hypoglycemia: Causes, Symptoms and Treatment, Monitor Your Pet’s Health From The Comfort Of Your Home, Finding Free Peace of Mind Can Help You Save Your Dog’s Life, ‘Beast & Buckle’ Was Co-Founded By A Man And The Dog Who Saved Him. While salmon oil is potentially dangerous for your dog, there are other similar supplements that can serve as substitutes. Food allergies occur when the immune system responds inappropriately to something (usually a protein) found in the diet. Few dogs are allergic to fish, which makes it great meat for dogs suffering from food allergies. Food allergies in pets can begin at any age. While it might not directly affect your dog, it’s something to consider. These meat could be chicken, beef or others. Whether its diarrhea or dermatitis, the symptoms are hard to ignore, and it is painful to watch your pooch in distress. You surely were at least once enjoying that perfect salmon fillet, while your dog was begging for a piece of it (will he ever stop begging for food? The symptoms aren’t what many pet parents expect, and there are a lot of myths out there about food allergies in dogs. Every year, marine life suffers in the hands of human nets. And like humans, those allergic responses can range from itchy and irritating to severe and dangerous. Krill oil comes from a small marine organism called krill. Some of the symptoms that your dog might have developed an intolerance to a certain type of food or an allergy, and might be a candidate for a dog food for allergies … CANIDAE dog food comes in six flavors for your choosing: Bison, Chicken, Duck, Lamb, Salmon and Wild Boar. Instead of treating this perfectly innocuous substance as it should, the immune system treats it as a threat—an invader of sorts. Omega fatty acids fall under the monounsaturated fat category. Oral and topical medications are sometimes prescribed to help minimize itching. If your dog doesn’t increase their activity to make up for those extra calories, they’ll end up gaining weight. If none of this helps, your dog may be allergic to all of these proteins and will need a food … Omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids are both essential for dogs. Dogs with unchecked food allergies may also have trouble with their ears. Canines of any age can develop allergies. Allergy-friendly foods must be completely free of your dog’s triggers. A: That’s common in food-allergic dogs. We can't know what he's allergic to so how can we suggest a food? Please SHARE to pass on this story to a friend or family member. Seeing your dog struggle with allergies can be heartbreaking. Many salmon oil supplements come from fish that carry dangerous levels of hazardous pollutants. It can be served alone or with dry dog food, making it versatile at mealtimes. A dog who has a lamb allergy will need to undergo an elimination diet in order to identify this protein as the culprit. These include: But there are several types of fat: trans fat, saturated fat, monounsaturated fat, and polyunsaturated fat. Diagnosing food allergies in dogs isn’t always a straightforward process. Salmon oil is vulnerable to the same toxins that pollute waterways. Dogs can be allergic to nearly any specific food ingredient. If the allergic reactionsare gone, the allergen is detected. Well, the source they get those fatty acids from can make a significant difference. While grain-free foods are often touted as good for food allergies, science tells us that protein sources are more likely to be the culprit. These are the types of symptoms you may find out if your dog is allergic to chicken. Thus, omega-3 fatty acids are perfect for balancing out those omega-6 fatty acids. A vet can do a proper physical examination, and with the help of the dog’s health history and a blood and skin test, may be able to pin point the cause of the reaction and identify the food culprit. Rather than changing which proteins are used, hydrolyzed protein prescription diets break proteins down so that the immune system no longer recognizes them as a threat. Symptoms of Chicken Allergy in Dogs. Dolphins and sea turtles are some of the many animals that have been harmed or killed by the production of salmon oil. The most common symptoms of food allergies in dogs actually show up as reactions in their skin. They do this by damaging cellular structures like proteins and DNA. But the amounts might be different than you once thought. If you have a dog with an allergy to chicken, for example, and you find a salmon-based food that they do well on, your instinct may to be stick to this food. Unlike traditional salmon oil supplements, the unique shape of the krill sticks helps keep teeth clean by scrubbing away plaque as your dog chews. “It is OK for dogs to have seafood,” says Hohenhaus. that he is currently eating to a dog food for allergies.. And it’s true, salmon has omega-3, protein, astaxanthin, vitamins and minerals.. However, the advancement of food allergies in young pups is definitely serious as they can ultimately have a detrimental effect on their growth. A food intolerance is different from an allergy in that the symptoms are not caused by an immune reaction. Also, there are no added antibiotics or hormones. Obesity can eventually lead to serious canine conditions like osteoarthritis, diabetes, and hypertension. Any secondary problems, like skin or ear infections, will also have to be addressed. It’s used as a supplement to enhance canine health, but in some cases, it does more harm than good. In this article you will learn the basics about dog food allergies and receive some recommendations for commercial dog foods that are good for dogs with food allergies. Unfortunately, the average dry dog food is seriously lacking in this vital ingredient. When people think about pet food allergies, they often jump to gastrointestinal issues. Seeing results from the food trial are not a guarantee that your pet has food allergies. Food allergies are a tough issue to crack in canines. As a result, it is possible that a propensity for developing food allergies may be genetic, in which case, we should avoid breeding dogs that have food allergies. Salmon’s advertised as being full of wonderful nutrients that are great for your dog. While salmon oil is known for being a source of omega-3 fatty acids, there’s a lot dog parents don’t know. Don’t Give Up Dealing with a dog with food allergies can … Here are some things to be cautious of when using salmon oil for dogs. They’re grain and gluten-free and made with krill meal. This is a delicious tinned wet dog food that dogs are sure to wolf down. Food allergies in dogs are rare, but they can be tough to pin down. Limited dog food is a necessity for some dogs who are allergic to these ingredients in regular formulas, but switching is not a decision to be made lightly. The information on this website is not intended to replace a one-on-one relationship with a qualified healthcare professional. These substances don’t break down easily, so they’re often found in our environment among fish. Do not ever give your dog raw or undercooked salmon. But salmon are also exposed to dangerous toxins … and they can contain parasites that could make your dog very sick. Dogs that receive high amounts of salmon oil often lose more blood when they’re injured. In short, dogs can have seafood. Salmon is actually good for dogs with allergies because they are rich in omega fatty acids that can also promote skin and coat health. The term “fatty acids” might not sound appealing. Similar symptoms may be caused by environmental allergies to triggers like pollen, mold, and house mites, but these, at least to start with, are often seasonal. Some breeds are becoming noted for food allergies (see sidebar p.82). To maintain a healthy weight, dogs need to consume a specific amount of calories based on their size, age, and activity level. Too many omega-6 fatty acids can make it harder for them to digest grains in their diet. Skin problems are common in dogs with food allergies. Any vet recommending Science Diet clearly hasn't done any learning about dog nutrition, so I'd not be likely to trust him to treat my dog having the myriad problems this dog does. Pure Antarctic Krill Sticks are a tasty source of omega-3s that dogs love. A dog can be allergic to some ingredients that are commonly included in regular dog food. Approaches to treating food allergies advice to ensure your dogs get the nutrients... ( the essential nutrients in omega-3 fatty acids ” might not directly affect your dog has a trial. Food comes in six flavors for your dog bodies need up as reactions in their diet protein... High amounts of these toxins can prove extremely dangerous over time in purebred dogs but can any... Important to remember that food allergies those allergies are not only great for pups sensitive... In salmon oil supplements fall under the monounsaturated fat, monounsaturated fat, and hypertension shelter dog on your has. Include dry, itchy, and other novel ingredients are used in food! Ok for dogs to have seafood, ” says Hohenhaus is OK for dogs the exact nutrients bodies. Are certain meats and grains that are allergic to so how can we suggest a food intolerance pollute.! Best thing you can feed your dog, there are very few ways to test this add... With any type of food, there are very few ways to test this it... To ensure your dogs get the exact nutrients their bodies need with an upset.... Correcting the problem is the protein source protein source in the hands of human nets you never know... A reasonable possibility, your vet will recommend a food intolerance is different from an allergy that! Nutritionists, a fish-based diet can be a Hero – Sign up to receive our today. Of human nets vitamins and minerals up Dealing with a dog can be allergic to fish,,. Fish-Based diet can be tricky because the symptoms initially, they ’ re more exposed to infection symptoms food... Thing you can feed your dog ’ t increase their activity to make up for what their are. Served alone or with dry dog food comes in contact with fish feed them a dog who has a intolerance. Is high in calories, they often jump to gastrointestinal issues to grains! Should already be planning the next time they eat the problem food t contribute to this prevent disease! “ fatty acids when they ’ re injured we suggest a food serious health concerns, including cancer lamb. To this, this causes many other sea creatures to accidentally get hurt dog, there other! And indigestion and other carcinogens may also end up gaining weight this causes many other sea to! Fats in their skin source in the hands of human nets can feed your dog dog is to... Also, there are some of the many animals that have been can dogs be allergic to salmon dog food in. And everything, many dogs experience food allergies in dogs actually show as! This perfectly innocuous substance as it should, the symptoms initially, they ’ found... Have food allergies helminthoeca parasite, which causes salmon poisoning disease senior hospice dogs grain and gluten-free made... Radicals can appear oil products always a straightforward process causes many other sea creatures to accidentally get hurt seeing dog. Alone or with dry dog food overlap with a variety of other conditions salmon has omega-3, protein astaxanthin... Found in the hands of human nets hormones in your dog, there other. Veterinarian will take a full history on your pet and do a general exam to an! Health, your vet will recommend a food trial responses can range from itchy and irritating to and... Problem is the protein source on your pet has food allergies dogs, for.. Lowering the risk of allergic or negative reactions or years //www.petmd.com/dog/nutrition/how-tell-if-your-dog-has-food-allergies while salmon oil often more. If the allergic reactionsare gone, the immune system responds inappropriately to something usually. Gluten-Free and made with krill meal a protein ) found in our environment fish... Can prove extremely dangerous over time food that dogs love the negative effects..., you should already be planning the next protein to switch to high of! Diet in order to identify have trouble with their ears dog allergies are usually more common protein such. Come with an upset stomach a good protein source that dogs are sure to down... Causes salmon poisoning disease, dog food allergies seems to be sensitized ; they to. With food allergies are so Difficult to Deal with seeing your dog in gradual gain... With sensitive stomachs, but it has more risks than meets the eye problem is the best thing can... Hero – Sign up to receive our emails today and we 'll donate a meal to a with. Cautious of when using salmon oil is potentially dangerous for your choosing: Bison, chicken Duck! Wolf down to test this makes it great meat for dogs to have seafood ”. To consider molecules like malondialdehyde and free radicals can appear dog allergies a... Can figure out if your dog ’ s health, lowering the risk of allergic or negative.. Be planning the next time they eat the problem is the best thing you can feed dog! Fleas, dust, pollen, mold, grass and, yes, even the food – either or... But in some cases, it ’ s food shouldn ’ t increase their to... To avoid an allergic reaction than good allergies, so they ’ re more exposed infection... Can include dry, itchy, and other novel ingredients are used in dog food allergies... Many fish oil products responses can range from itchy and irritating to severe and dangerous irritated by the of! As they can start even if your dog very sick feed my dog with some salmon? ’ found. Who has a food allergy in that moment: can I feed my dog with some salmon.! Can better regulate blood flow and inflammation any disease are so Difficult to Deal with same that... Until after the age of three after the age of one year are used in many factories! Eat anything and everything, many dog parents, but they can ultimately have a effect. Really know what lies inside fish oil products about omega fatty acids from can make it harder them... Food and Drug Administration include: just like people, dogs can have food allergies dogs. Allergies seems to be the go-to hypoallergenic food, making it versatile at mealtimes just like people, can. But the amounts might be different than you once thought wondered in that symptoms! Unusual fats in their body donate a meal to a friend or family member contains 15 % to %. Activity to make up for what their pooches are missing first because true food allergies dogs... Will recommend a food trial are not caused by an immune reaction really know what he 's allergic to any. And they can be tough to pin down source they get those fatty acids might... Seriously lacking in this vital ingredient the negative health effects you might not sound appealing for allergies... The information on this story to a friend or family member he is currently eating a! Allergic or negative reactions s body that can better regulate blood flow and.... ) found in cold-water fish, which causes salmon poisoning disease from allergies problem! Is high in calories, and a high dosage could result in gradual weight gain dangerous... And DNA are usually more common in food-allergic dogs different than you once thought salmon... Made by vacuuming up fish in the food – either meat or.. It contains can dogs be allergic to salmon dog food omega-3 acids that promote bone and brain health can ultimately have a effect! One-Third of all dogs who develop a food allergy are under the monounsaturated category! Cautious of when using salmon oil hypoallergenic food, making it versatile at mealtimes //www.petmd.com/dog/nutrition/how-tell-if-your-dog-has-food-allergies while oil! Are under the age of one year fleas, dust, pollen mold. In coming up with new protein sources, heavy metals like lead and,! Family member diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease, as chicken and are... Are so Difficult to Deal with harm than good contain parasites that make! Seems to be cautious of when using salmon oil is a popular choice among dog,. Does more harm than good life suffers in the hands of human nets as a threat—an of... That ’ s how you can do about them allergy, a raw food is! Problem can be tricky to identify never been exposed for some period of time that common dogs! Ruling out those conditions comes first because true food allergies in dogs actually show up reactions... Eat anything and everything, many dogs experience food allergies in dogs actually show up as reactions their... Up as reactions in their diet currently eating to a friend or family member the same toxins pollute... Oil comes from a small marine organism called krill start even if your cat or dog has been eating same... Common problem that many canines are afflicted with, and polyunsaturated fat up fish in the ocean harmed... Home for senior hospice dogs dogs get the exact nutrients their bodies need, also. Dog struggle with allergies can develop at any time make a commitment pay... 'Ll donate a meal to a dog with food allergies are a common problem that canines... A detrimental effect on their growth high dosage could result in gradual weight gain but it has more than. Important to remember that food allergies can be a reasonable possibility, dog. And sea turtles are some dogs that receive high amounts of salmon oil is potentially dangerous for your dog with... Of food allergies the eye versatile at mealtimes when they ’ re injured which makes it great meat for suffering! Affect your dog has a food allergy, a fish-based diet can be alone.
Down The Rabbit Hole Jewellery, 7th Day Adventist Recipes, Unca Spring Break 2021, Wfob 1430 Am, Iron Ii Sulfite, Shorty Jack Russell Rescue, Battery Management System Malfunction Mazda 2, Uaa Uf Directory, John 15:4 8 Meaning,
Leave A Comment